Downshifting challenge: clothing week part two

In the second part of my challenge to apply the principles of downshifting to clothes shopping, I have been busy trialing my purchases. If you remember, earlier this week I bought cheap briefs, socks and pyjamas from a discount store called TJ Hughes, along with more briefs, socks and a cardigan from Primark. These are all stock items which many of us might buy from a more expensive store – rightly or wrongly – to try to ensure they are good quality. So how did my purchases compare?

The Primark briefs were very comfortable, a good shape and survived my wash without the dye running. One of my friends said she found that they often shrink in her machine, so I washed them at 30 degrees instead of the advised 40 (I normally wash everything at 30 degrees anyway) and they came out fine. I’ll be interested to see how they fare after multiple washes, though. That said, I find that M&S briefs don’t always last as well as they used to.

The TJ Hughes pants were shapeless already before they went in the wash. I felt slightly itchy wearing them too – although my neighbour pointed out that this may have been psychological. I can’t get my head around the idea that a pair of underpants could only cost 20p. DJ joked that at that price you could buy new ones every week (like Princess Di was rumoured to) and compost them rather than throw them out. But, to be fair, originally the price was £2.50 for a packet of six.

The socks from both stores were good quality, comfortable and washed well. However, DJ pulled a face when he saw me in my £3.99 pyjamas. While the leggings were ok, the top didn’t sit well and was clingy in all the wrong places. They were really comfortable to sleep in, though, I’ll give them that.

I made the fatal error of falling in love with my Primark cardigan. I became anxious about sacrificing it to the challenge and the perils of my washing machine. I was afraid it might lose its shape or run in the wash. Fortunately, while it was a bit creased by the time it came out, the colour hadn’t run and I’m hoping that with some careful ironing it will reclaim its former glory.

Lesley posed a good question in her comment this week – while we may save money wearing cheaper clothes, what is the human cost in terms of the factory sweatshop workers who are making them? I have to say that this has been on my mind a lot this week. We’ve become used to cheap clothes and throwaway fashions, but how ethical are they? Checking the labels in my purchases this week, it struck me that not a single label stated where the items were made.

Kerri, who had seen the 2008 BBC programme Blood Sweat and T-shirts, said that the actual mark-up on products isn’t always a good guide because some more expensive companies save money by having their clothes made in sweatshops too. I was disappointed, if not surprised, to hear this. So just because the clothes cost more, it doesn’t mean that they aren’t sweatshop clothes. To be certain, you need to buy charity shop clothes, make your own or shop in a store committed to fair trade which aren’t always easy to find according to this blog.

But ethics aside, I was pleasantly surprised by most of my items. I think the test will really be to see how they fare over the longer term, though, and how long they last. It may still work out  better value for money to buy better quality items elsewhere that will stand the test of time.

Do ethical concerns stop you from buying cheap clothes or is price always paramount? Leave a message and let me know.

Share It

 del.icio.us   Digg   Facebook   Google 
 Live Spaces   MySpace   Newsvine   Reddit 
 StumbleUpon   Technorati   Twitter   Yahoo! My Web 
Advertisements
This entry was posted in Challenge. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Downshifting challenge: clothing week part two

  1. Piper says:

    Hi Jacqueline. Thanks for your comment. I know what you mean – people can be snooty! But when I visited Primark the other day it was full of people from all walks of life. Thanks for the George tip – will have to check out their latest range. Our local Asda is getting a clothes section soon.

  2. Christine says:

    It\’s not just the cost of clothes but the number that you feel you need that can swing the balance. If you have a few good quality items that never really go out of fashion and lots of inexpensive accessories you can surely mix and match so that you never look the same two days in a row but don\’t need quantity. It\’s hard drawing the line between want and need isn\’t it though?

  3. david says:

    The main problem with a lot of cheap clothing is, it was probably made by women and children held in conditions of slavery. So if you can, please look at the label and ask.

  4. Glyn says:

    If fashion is your prime reason for buying that \’just got to have\’ item, then it\’s the cheaper alternative every time. Why pay a fortune out on something to wear this year when next year it\’ll be something else? If you have cash to burn then fair enough, but lets face it; something that you\’ll only wear for a couple of months or so doesn\’t need that high quality label anyway.

  5. maria says:

    i always buy my clothes from asda except my trousers?

  6. Ripon and Harrogate Tutors says:

    Charity shops are a wonderful place to get clothes and still feel the retail therapy buzz at the same time. Typical purchases I make are branded jeans and t shirts, e.g a pair of diesel jeans for for £3.99 that would retail at at least £80. You just can\’t lose at these prices and it also encourages to experiment and \’splash out\’ but in a very modest way of course!

  7. S says:

    I won\’t buy \’sweatshop\’ brands. I look where items are made. I also buy from charity shops. Lastly, style before fashion.

  8. Kerri says:

    buying from charity shops doesn\’t necessarily guarantee that clothes haven\’t been made in \’sweatshops\’ as it doesn\’t change the provenance of the article. On the subject of how well things last, I\’ve bought expensive items that haven\’t lasted well at all, and cheap ones that have (and vice versa). I guess the key question when buying items is how much you need it, how much you want it and can you really afford it.

  9. piper says:

    Good point, Kerri. Many things in charity shops may also have been made in sweat shops so I retract that point, and you\’re right about the quality of things varying. I had a nice suit from M&S years ago which I bought for an interview and the knees went in the trousers after about a year. But I have a £10 jacket from Primark which I\’ve had for 7 years and is still going strong.

  10. simsjohan says:

    If you have a few good quality items that never really go out of fashion and lots of inexpensive accessories you can surely mix and match so that you never look the same two days in a row.Savings Interest Rate

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s